Retargeting Magic: How to Win Back Customers and Boost Conversions

Strategic Advisor Board

In the vast universe of digital marketing, there's a powerful spell that top brands cast to reclaim lost opportunities it's called retargeting. Imagine browsing online for a pair of shoes, deciding to abandon the cart, only to have those very shoes reappear on various sites, gently nudging you to make the purchase. That’s retargeting in action. But how does it work, and more importantly, how can businesses leverage it to win back customers and boost their conversions? In this guide, we'll pull back the curtain on the enchanting world of retargeting, revealing the strategies and insights that can transform a missed opportunity into a loyal customer. Whether you're a seasoned marketer or a newbie trying to improve your brand's digital footprint, the magic of retargeting awaits to be unveiled. Let’s embark on this journey together.

The Science Behind Retargeting

In our rapidly advancing digital era, retargeting might seem like wizardry, but in truth, it’s a blend of sophisticated technology and deep-rooted psychological principles. Let’s uncover the science that makes retargeting so effective.

Understanding Customer Behavior and Drop-off Points

Every digital footprint a user leaves from clicking an ad to abandoning a shopping cart is a breadcrumb of data. Advanced algorithms and tracking tools, like pixels or cookies, trace these breadcrumbs. They help marketers understand why a potential customer veered away at the last moment. Was it the price? Was the checkout process cumbersome? Or perhaps they just got distracted. By analyzing these drop-off points, businesses can craft pinpointed messages to address those very hesitations.

The Psychology of Repetition and Brand Recognition

Familiarity breeds comfort. This psychological axiom, known as the ‘mere exposure effect’, states that people tend to develop a preference for things merely because they are familiar with them. In retargeting, when users repeatedly see an ad for a product they once browsed, it enhances brand recognition. Over time, this repeated exposure makes the product or brand seem more trustworthy and appealing, increasing the likelihood of a conversion.

Cookie-based Technology: The Digital Spellbook

At the core of retargeting is cookie-based technology. When a user visits a website, a small piece of code (often referred to as a pixel) places an anonymous retargeting “cookie” in their browser. This cookie is the key ingredient that enables retargeting platforms to identify and serve retargeted ads, ensuring that these ads reach people who've previously interacted with a particular brand or product.

Dynamic Retargeting: Personalization at Its Best

Instead of showing the same generic ad to every past visitor, dynamic retargeting uses the information collected from the user's browsing behavior to showcase specific products or services they showed interest in. This high level of personalization resonates more with users, as it feels tailor-made for their needs and interests.

Short-term Memory and Retargeting’s Golden Window

Humans have a fleeting short-term memory. Often, potential customers might forget about a product they were interested in, especially if they were merely browsing. However, retargeting capitalizes on this short-term memory window. By reintroducing the product within a short period (typically within a few days), it stays fresh in the potential buyer’s mind, thereby increasing the chances of a completed purchase.

Setting Up a Retargeting Campaign

Delving into the world of retargeting can be a game-changer for businesses aiming to recapture potential customers. Establishing an effective retargeting campaign requires a strategic approach, a clear understanding of your target audience, and the right tools. Let's walk through the essential steps and considerations to set up a successful retargeting campaign:

Define Clear Campaign Objectives

Before diving into the mechanics, establish clear objectives. Do you want to:

⦁ Increase sales of a particular product?

⦁ Boost overall website traffic?

⦁ Encourage sign-ups or subscriptions?

⦁ Having clear goals will guide your campaign structure and measurement metrics.

Choose the Right Tools and Platforms

⦁ Retargeting Platforms: There are numerous platforms like AdRoll, Criteo, or the built-in retargeting capabilities of Google Ads and Facebook Ads Manager.

⦁ Tracking Tools: Ensure you have tracking pixels or cookies set up on your website. These tools will track visitors and their actions, helping you gather data for retargeting.

Segment Your Audience for Effective Retargeting

Not all visitors to your website are the same. Segmenting your audience allows you to serve personalized ads that resonate more effectively. Consider segmenting based on:

⦁ Pages or products viewed

⦁ Stage in the buying cycle (e.g., cart abandoners vs. homepage visitors)

⦁ Previous purchase history

Create Compelling Ad Content

⦁ Relevant Messaging: Ensure the ad speaks directly to the segment's actions. For instance, cart abandoners might see an ad that says, "Forgot something? Complete your purchase now."

⦁ Visuals: Use high-quality images, preferably of the products the potential customer viewed.

⦁ Calls to Action (CTAs): These should be clear and persuasive. "Shop Now," "Return to Cart," or "See What's New" are some examples.

Determine Ad Placement and Budget

⦁ Ad Placement: Depending on your audience, decide where your retargeted ads will appear. This could be on social media platforms, search engines, or partner websites.

⦁ Budget: Like any advertising campaign, set a daily or overall budget. Retargeting often offers a high ROI, but it’s essential to monitor and adjust your spending based on results.

Set Up Frequency Caps

It's essential to strike a balance in ad frequency. You want to remind visitors without overwhelming or annoying them. By setting a frequency cap, you can control how often a single user will see your ad within a specific timeframe.

Monitor, Analyze, and Adjust

Once your campaign is live:

⦁ Monitor: Use analytics tools to see how your ads are performing.

⦁ Analyze: Determine which segments, messages, or platforms are yielding the best results.

⦁ Adjust: Based on the data, tweak your campaigns. This might mean reallocating budget, changing ad copy, or refining audience segments.

Keep an Eye on Compliance

With evolving digital privacy laws and browser updates affecting cookies, ensure you're compliant with regulations like GDPR or CCPA. Inform visitors about cookies, and obtain necessary permissions.

Optimizing Your Retargeting Strategy

A well-executed retargeting campaign can be the linchpin for many businesses to win back customers and boost conversions. However, even the most carefully crafted campaigns require ongoing optimization to ensure you're reaching your audience effectively and obtaining the highest possible ROI. Here's how you can fine-tune your retargeting strategy:

Dive Deep into Analytics

⦁ Performance Metrics: Regularly review key metrics like click-through rates (CTR), conversion rates, and cost per conversion. These will provide insights into what's working and where improvements are needed.

⦁ Audience Insights: Utilize tools that give a deeper understanding of your audience’s behavior, segment performance, and interaction with your ads.

Refine Audience Segments

⦁ Retargeting List Duration: Adjust the duration for how long a visitor remains in your retargeting list. Someone who visited a month ago might not have the same intent as someone who visited yesterday.

⦁ Expand Segmentation Criteria: Consider further segmenting audiences based on the time spent on site, geolocation, or device type.

A/B Testing for Ad Variations

Continuously test various elements of your ads to see which versions resonate more with your audience:

⦁ Ad Copy: Test different CTAs, headlines, or promotional messages.

⦁ Visual Elements: Experiment with different product images, color schemes, or ad designs.

⦁ Landing Pages: Sometimes, the ad isn’t the issue; it's where the ad takes the user. Test different landing pages to improve conversion rates.

Adjust Retargeting Frequency

Frequency Balance: If an individual sees the same ad too frequently, it can lead to banner blindness or even annoyance. Adjust the frequency to find a sweet spot where your ads are noticed but not intrusive.

Cross-Platform Retargeting

If you’ve been retargeting on just one platform, consider expanding:

⦁ Multi-device: Ensure you're reaching users no matter the device they're using – from desktop to mobile.

⦁ Cross-channel: Expand beyond just one platform. If you started with Facebook retargeting, consider incorporating Google Display Network or vice versa.

Re-evaluate Your Offer

⦁ Value Proposition: Perhaps you need a stronger incentive to lure back potential customers. Consider limited-time offers, discounts, or exclusive content as enticements.

⦁ Urgency and Scarcity: Experiment with messages that instill urgency (e.g., "Last day to buy!") or scarcity (e.g., "Only 3 items left in stock!").

Stay Updated with Retargeting Technologies

Retargeting tools, platforms, and best practices evolve. Keep abreast of the latest technologies, tools, and trends in retargeting to ensure you're leveraging the most effective strategies.

Ensure Positive Brand Experience

⦁ Ad Relevance: Make sure your ads are relevant and not misleading. Irrelevant ads can harm your brand image and reduce trust.

⦁ Feedback Loop: Encourage feedback from your audience. If people find your ads intrusive or irrelevant, it's crucial to know and adjust accordingly.

Consider the Bigger Picture

Integrate retargeting with other marketing strategies. For instance, combining email marketing with retargeting can amplify the impact of both campaigns.

Advanced Techniques and Best Practices

Retargeting is a dynamic realm within the digital marketing space. As businesses grow more accustomed to basic retargeting strategies, the need to stand out becomes paramount. Let's delve into advanced techniques and best practices to ensure your retargeting campaigns are a cut above the rest.

Sequential Retargeting for Storytelling

Instead of repeatedly showing the same ad, tell a story over a sequence of ads. This not only provides a fresh approach with each view but also allows for deeper brand engagement. The viewer moves through a series of messages, keeping them engaged and leading them closer to conversion with each step.

Layering Audience Segments

By combining different audience attributes, you can create ultra-specific segments. For example, retarget users who viewed a product, stayed on the page for over two minutes, but didn’t make a purchase. This combination can help tailor more precise and compelling messages.

Cross-Selling and Upselling

Retargeting isn’t just for winning back lost customers. Use it to cross-sell related products or upsell premium versions to your existing customers. For instance, if a customer bought a camera, retarget them with ads for camera accessories.

Time-Decay Models

Adjust the weightage of your audience segments based on recency. Visitors who engaged with your site recently are more valuable than those who visited weeks ago. By utilizing a time-decay model, you prioritize and allocate more budget to retargeting recent visitors.

Engagement-Based Retargeting

Target users based on the depth of their engagement. For example, someone who watched 80% of your product video might be more interested than someone who clicked off after 10%. Segment and target these users differently.

Geo-Targeting and Event-Based Retargeting

If you're promoting an event or a local store, retarget users based on their location or proximity. For example, if you have a sale at a specific branch, retarget users who are nearby.

Frequency Capping Across Platforms

While you might set frequency caps within individual platforms, remember that users often engage across multiple channels. Implement a holistic approach to frequency capping considering all platforms to avoid overexposure.

Collaborative Filtering

Taking a page out of recommendation engines, use collaborative filtering. If a user showed interest in a product, showcase other products that similar users have liked or purchased.

Incorporate Feedback Mechanisms

Allow users to provide feedback on ads. Platforms like Facebook have started enabling this. By knowing why an ad isn't resonating, you can refine your approach.

Stay Updated on Privacy Regulations

With rising concerns about data privacy, tools like cookies are undergoing changes. Ensure you're compliant with GDPR, CCPA, and other regional regulations. Regularly update your methods in response to evolving browser policies around tracking.

Conclusion

Retargeting is an artful dance between technology and human psychology, a blend of sophisticated tools and nuanced strategies. In today's digital age, where customer attention is both fragmented and fleeting, retargeting emerges as a powerful ally in a brand's quest for engagement and conversion. As with any marketing technique, the key lies in constant evolution – understanding the basics, optimizing regularly, and staying abreast of advanced tactics. Embrace retargeting not just as a standalone strategy, but as an integral piece of your overarching digital marketing puzzle. With the right approach, every lost visitor represents not an end, but a fresh opportunity for re-engagement and conversion. Dive in, iterate, and watch the magic unfold.

This article was brought to you by: Jason Miller, AKA Jason "The Bull" Miller, Founder/CEO and Senior Global Managing Partner of the Strategic Advisor Board - What has your business done for YOU today?

The Strategic Advisor Board is designed to help you get over, around or through so you can reach your next goal. That is what we were built for and we are really good. Just reach out and touch us here to setup a call and have a quick conversation with our team today.

SAB Foresight

Receive updates and insights

SAB Foresight Signup Form

Thank you for subscribing.

You will receive the next newsletter as soon as it is available.

GPDR

CCPA